Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Gregory Baus's avatar

Brad, when point 11 says "Christians are commanded to... submit to [these magistrates] unless they command us to do evil," is this intending to say that Christians are commanded to *always* submit to magistrates with the *sole* exception of when they command us to sin? If so, that would contradict the WCF.

23.4 specifies "It is the duty of people... to obey their *lawful* commands, and to be subject to their authority, for *conscience* sake."

19.4 specifies "they who... oppose any *lawful* power, or the *lawful* exercise of it, whether it be civil or ecclesiastical, resist the ordinance of God."

Wouldn't you agree that these necessarily imply that it is *not* the duty of the people to obey a magistrate's unlawful commands, and that any one *may* oppose unlawful civil powers, and unlawful exercise of civil power? (And that, as C. Hodge and many others understood, such unlawfulness is not merely identical to commanding us to sin, but may include their commanding such things as are outside their God-given jurisdiction/authority?)

nick's avatar

Maybe it's more of a "reaffirnation" since all read Christians should be able to agree with what you wrote. Mr. Peacock doth err greatly in his comment btw, and Mr. Sims...well, you just don't pay him no mind.

6 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?